Lauding Their Soldiers, Putin and Zelensky Signal Long Fight Ahead
The scenes captured the intractability of a war that began nearly 10 months ago between two antagonists presenting very different versions of the conflict.
President Volodymyr Zelensky of Ukraine, wearing a plain army-green jacket, on Tuesday made perhaps his most dangerous trip to the front lines since the fighting began in February, traveling to the ravaged city of Bakhmut to hand out medals to soldiers as the thunder of artillery echoed in the distance.
At almost the same time, President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia summoned pro-war figures and propaganda leaders to an ornate hall in the Kremlin, where he honored them for their commitment to the invasion of Ukraine.
Mr. Putin’s televised event appeared aimed at showing his audience — both at home and abroad — that he was determined to continue the fight despite what American officials say are Russian casualties now exceeding 100,000 dead and wounded.
Mr. Zelensky’s visit to Bakhmut, whether by design or otherwise, stole some of the attention from Mr. Putin by showcasing the Ukrainian leader’s defiance and tolerance for personal risk in a city so devastated by repeated Russian assaults that it evokes images of the wastelands of World War I.
Ukraine’s success at retaining control of the city in the eastern Donbas region has lent it a symbolism that outstrips its military significance. “Bakhmut Holds,” read bumper stickers, artwork and T-shirts that can be found across Ukraine.
“The east is holding out because Bakhmut is fighting,” Mr. Zelensky said as he presented medals to Ukrainian soldiers and posed for photos. “This is the fortress of our morale. In fierce battles and at the cost of many lives, freedom is being defended here for all of us.”
Mr. Putin, too, appeared to be steeling his citizens for a difficult fight ahead.
He honored the Russia-installed leaders of four Ukrainian regions that Moscow illegally annexed in September, though parts of the areas remain under Ukrainian control. And he recognized Semyon Pegov, a widely read Russian war blogger who was injured in Ukraine, and Margarita Simonyan, the hard-line editor of the RT television network, one of the Kremlin’s most important propaganda outlets.
“Thank you for wresting our people out of the bloody mouths of these man-eaters, despite the pain and the blood,” Ms. Simonyan said, in an apparent reference to the Kremlin’s false claim that Ukraine has been perpetrating a genocide against Russian speakers. “And we will help you whack these man-eaters as much as you demand it from us.”
The State of the War
- A Botched Invasion: Secret battle plans, intercepts and interviews with soldiers and Kremlin confidants offer new insight into the stunning failures of Russia’s military in Ukraine.
- A New Russian Offensive? A top adviser to President Volodymyr Zelensky said Ukraine is bracing for the possibility that Russia will sharply escalate the war in a winter offensive that could include mass infantry attacks.
- Putin in Belarus: President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia made a rare visit to Belarus, raising concerns in Ukraine that Russian forces could aim again at Kyiv, which is near the Belarusian border.
- The War in the Skies: As Ukrainian officials warn of a new Russian ground offensive, waves of Russian missiles continue to batter Ukraine’s infrastructure. The attacks are leaving a trail of destruction and grief.
It was a reminder that Moscow’s powerful propaganda apparatus, like Mr. Putin himself, has increasingly begun to acknowledge Russian struggles at the front, even if it still masks the extent of the losses. At the same time, Russian propaganda is presenting the war as existential — claiming that the true enemy is a NATO that seeks Russia’s destruction — and trying to brace Russians for further sacrifice.
Mr. Putin, in a brief speech at the end of the ceremony, said these were “difficult, unusual times,” and praised Russian soldiers as “heroes.”
“When a country or even every person develops, moves forward, it always overcomes certain difficulties on this path,” Mr. Putin said. “But today, it’s indeed being accompanied by particular challenges.”
Hours earlier, Mr. Putin released a video message addressed to the employees of Russia’s security agencies in which he warned that the situation in Russian-held parts of Ukraine was “extremely difficult.”
In response, Mr. Putin suggested he would crack down harder. In a transcript of the video address released by the Kremlin, the Russian leader called on his security agencies to intensify their efforts “to put a firm stop to the activities of foreign special services and to promptly identify traitors, spies and diversionists.”
Mr. Putin has been projecting an image in recent days of a leader more directly involved in the invasion.
On Friday, he made an unannounced visit to a military command post coordinating the fight, the Kremlin said, without disclosing the location. And on Monday, he made a rare visit to Belarus to strengthen military and economic bonds with the country’s authoritarian president, a close ally who has allowed the Russian military to use his territory as a staging ground for the war.
In Ukraine, concern has been intensifying that Russia may be planning a new offensive that could include a second attempt to seize Kyiv, the capital. Russia is planning the assault, Ukrainian officials say, even as it continues to attack Ukraine’s power plants and other important infrastructure in an effort to deprive the country of heat and light in the winter.
Energy officials say the attacks have left Kyiv with enough power for only about 20 percent of the city’s 3.3 million residents, forcing utilities to institute longer and more unpredictable outages to keep the grid stable.
Some analysts have said it would be difficult for Russia to launch a larger offensive, since its forces have been worn down from 10 months of fighting and the recent battlefield successes of the Ukrainian military.
A senior State Department official said on Tuesday that top Russian officials were torn about whether to undertake a new offensive, with Moscow’s military leaders engaged in an internal debate over escalation.
The official said that Washington was seeing “conflicting things” in the debate. Some officials are pushing for the offensive, while others question whether Russia has the capacity for it, the official said. The official spoke on the condition of anonymity because of the sensitivities around diplomacy and intelligence.
The official did not detail the intelligence that Washington was using as a window into the internal Russian debate. And because of the disagreement there, the official said, it is unclear where “their actual actions will go.”
The Ukrainians, pointing to Moscow’s recent conscription of about 300,000 additional troops, fear that Russia intends to launch a ground offensive. And Russia has been signaling to the West that despite its heavy casualties, it is prepared for far more.
Sergei Naryshkin, the chief of Russia’s foreign intelligence service, told the head of the C.I.A., William J. Burns, last month that Russia would never give up, no matter how many troops it lost on the battlefield, The New York Times reported.One NATO member has warned allies that Mr. Putin is ready to accept the deaths or injuries of as many as 300,000 Russian troops, roughly three times his estimated losses so far.
Edward Wong and Carly Olson contributed reporting.